Start here
One Pan Beef Stroganoff
by Erin O'Brien on Instagram
- 35 min
- Serves 4
- 14 ingredients
- Only this version uses
- ground beef, half-and-half, cornstarch and parsley
3 creator recipes compared
3 ways creators make beef stroganoff
Erin O'Brien, Pedro Forato and Loving Life Fam have each posted a version of beef stroganoff on Instagram and YouTube. Most of them use garlic, beef broth and sour cream. Total time runs from 35 min to 45 min. Below, each one is compared on time, ingredients and method, with a link to the full recipe and the original video.
- 3 versions
- 3 creators
- 35 min to 45 min
- Instagram · YouTube
Side by side
From each creator's recipe as we saved it: total time, servings, ingredient count, cooking method, and what no other version uses.
| Version | Total time | Serves | Ingredients | Method | Only this one uses |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Erin O'BrienOne Pan Beef Stroganoff | 35 min | 4 | 14 | One pot · Simmered | ground beef, half-and-half, cornstarch and parsley |
| Pedro ForatoBeef Stroganoff | 45 min | 4 | 14 | One pot · Pan-fried · Simmered | beef sirloin, portobello mushroom, olive oil and cognac |
| Loving Life FamEasy Beef Stroganoff | 45 min | 4 | 10 | Pan-fried | beef steak strips, oyster mushrooms, flour and milk |
- Erin O'Brien35 min
One Pan Beef Stroganoff
- Serves
- 4
- Ingredients
- 14
- Method
- One pot · Simmered
- Only this one
- ground beef, half-and-half, cornstarch and parsley
- Pedro Forato45 min
Beef Stroganoff
- Serves
- 4
- Ingredients
- 14
- Method
- One pot · Pan-fried · Simmered
- Only this one
- beef sirloin, portobello mushroom, olive oil and cognac
- Loving Life Fam45 min
Easy Beef Stroganoff
- Serves
- 4
- Ingredients
- 10
- Method
- Pan-fried
- Only this one
- beef steak strips, oyster mushrooms, flour and milk
What most versions share
In all 3
- onion
In most of them
- garlic
- beef broth
- sour cream
Salt, pepper, oil and water are left out. Ingredient names are matched loosely, so chicken thighs and chicken legs both count as chicken.
Where they differ
- Erin O'Brien is the only one to use ground beef, half-and-half, cornstarch and parsley.
- Pedro Forato is the only one to use beef sirloin, portobello mushroom, olive oil and cognac.
- Loving Life Fam is the only one to use beef steak strips, oyster mushrooms, flour and milk.
- Erin O'Brien and Pedro Forato keep everything in one pot; Loving Life Fam doesn't.
- Erin O'Brien and Pedro Forato simmer, poach or braise; Loving Life Fam doesn't.
- Pedro Forato and Loving Life Fam pan-fry or sear; Erin O'Brien doesn't.
- Erin O'Brien takes the least time (35 min); Loving Life Fam the most (45 min).
- Loving Life Fam uses the shortest ingredient list (10); Pedro Forato the longest (14).
The other 2 versions
Pedro Forato · Instagram
Beef Stroganoff
- 45 min
- Serves 4
- 14 ingredients
Only this one uses beef sirloin, portobello mushroom, olive oil and cognac.
Loving Life Fam · YouTube
Easy Beef Stroganoff
- 45 min
- Serves 4
- 10 ingredients
Only this one uses beef steak strips, oyster mushrooms, flour and milk.
How this comparison works
Every version here was saved from the creator's own public video and turned into a structured recipe card. The comparison reads only those cards: ingredients, steps, times and servings. We haven't cooked these side by side or ranked them on taste.
Reposts and the same video saved twice count once. Times and servings come from each recipe card; short videos don't always state them, so treat them as a guide. Every version links to the creator's original video.