ReelsMealsSign inStart cooking

French onion soup: 3 creator recipes compared

Most use bone marrow and gruyere cheese. Some add carrot or stock.

  • 3 versions
  • 1 hr 25 min to 12 hr 45 min
  • Serves 4 to 6

Times are estimated preparation and cooking; chilling or resting is extra. Updated 5 November 2026.

Classic French Onion Soup by Bon Appétit, a frame from the YouTube video

Make this one first.

We put the most-saved version first: Bon Appétit’s. A classic French onion soup featuring sweet, caramelized onions in a rich, slow‑simmered beef stock, enriched with buttery roasted bone marrow, toasted baguette, and a decadent 50/50 blend of Gruyère and Comté cheese, finished with a splash of cognac.

Classic French Onion Soup from Bon Appétit’s YouTube video

The video loads from YouTube when you tap.

Classic French Onion Soup

Recipe from Bon Appétit, from their YouTube videoWritten down by ReelsMeals from the caption and voiceover.

  • 12 hr 45 min
  • Serves 6
  • 16 ingredients
  • Oven

The only one of the 3 with beef bones, garlic, bay leaf and black peppercorns.

Ingredients

Beef Stock

  • beef bones (oxtail, knuckles, marrow bones)
  • 2bay leaf
  • a pinchblack peppercorns
  • to tastesalt
  • 2 tbsptomato paste
  • 1/2 bottlered wine
  • 4 lwater

Caramelized Onions

  • 6onions
  • 3 clovesgarlic
  • a pinchsalt

Garnish & Assembly

  • 200 gbone marrow
  • 1baguette
  • 100 gGruyère cheese
  • 100 gComté cheese
  • 2 tbspchives
  • 1 tspcognac
  • a pinchblack pepper

How it goes

  1. Preheat the oven to 450 °F (230 °C). Spread the beef bones (including oxtail, knuckles, and marrow bones) on a sheet pan and roast for about 30 minutes, until deeply browned.

  2. While the bones roast, thinly slice six onions and set aside.

  3. In a large stockpot, combine the roasted bones with any pan drippings, 2 bay leaves, a pinch of black peppercorns, salt to taste, 2 tbsp tomato paste, 0.5 bottle red wine, and 4 L water. Bring to a boil, then reduce to a gentle simmer and cook for 6–12 hours, skimming occasionally.

  4. Strain the broth through a fine sieve, discard the solids, and keep the clear stock warm over low heat.

  5. In a separate large saucepan, melt a little butter or oil over medium heat. Add the sliced onions with a pinch of salt and cook slowly, stirring frequently, for about 1.5 hours until the onions are soft, golden, and deeply caramelized.

  6. During the last 10 minutes of onion cooking, add the minced garlic and stir briefly.

Then 7 more steps in the full recipe.

Open the full recipe

All 3, side by side.

From each creator’s recipe as we saved it. Time is the estimated preparation and cooking time; chilling is extra where they say so. Ingredient counts include everything on the list.

Sort by

10 min or less · 7 or fewer11 to 29 min · 8 or 930 min or more · 10 or more

3 French onion soup recipes compared by estimated time, servings, ingredients, method and what only that version uses. Bon Appétit’s, the one to make first, is highlighted.
VersionTime (est.)ServesIngredientsMethodOnly this one uses
Classic French Onion SoupBon Appétit · make this one first12 hr 45 min616Oven, Simmered, Blenderbeef bones, garlic, bay leaf and black peppercorns
French Onion SoupBon Appétit1 hr 45 min46No cookingcarrot, celery stalk, bread slice and cheese
Home-Friendly French Onion SoupSebastian Graus1 hr 25 min49Oven, Grilled, Simmeredstock, chickpeas, thyme and crusty bread

What they share.

  • All 3use onion.
  • 2 of 3use bone marrow. Sebastian Graus’s version leaves it out.
  • 2 of 3use gruyere cheese. Bon Appétit’s version leaves it out.

Counted from each version’s ingredient list. Salt, pepper, oil and water are left out, and names are matched loosely, so chicken thighs and chicken legs both count as chicken.

Where they differ.

  • How they cook it

    Bon Appétit and Sebastian Graus use the oven; Bon Appétit doesn't. Bon Appétit and Sebastian Graus simmer, poach or braise; Bon Appétit doesn't. Only Bon Appétit uses a blender. Only Bon Appétit needs no cooking. Only Sebastian Graus grills.

  • Something only one of them uses

    Bon Appétit is the only one to use beef bones, garlic, bay leaf and black peppercorns. Bon Appétit is the only one to use carrot, celery stalk, bread slice and cheese. Sebastian Graus is the only one to use stock, chickpeas, thyme and crusty bread.

  • What they serve it with

    Bon Appétit serves it with beef stock and caramelized onions.

  • Time and list length

    Sebastian Graus takes the least time (1 hr 25 min); Bon Appétit the most (12 hr 45 min). Bon Appétit uses the shortest ingredient list (6); Bon Appétit the longest (16).

All 3, with their videos.

Each one opens as a full recipe with the creator credited and the original video linked.

How this comparison works.

Every recipe here comes from a creator’s own video. ReelsMeals writes it down from the caption and the voiceover, and publishes it with the creator named and the original linked. When three or more versions of a dish from at least two creators are saved, the dish gets a page like this one. Reposts and the same video saved twice count once.

Times and servings come from the saved recipe cards and may be estimated. Ingredient names are matched loosely, so chicken thighs and chicken legs both count as chicken. We don’t rank them by taste: the version shown first is the one ReelsMeals cooks have saved most. Last updated 5 November 2026.

Is one of these yours? Email [email protected] to correct it or take it down.

Turn your own saved reel into a recipe

More dishes, compared.

Or browse all 133 dishes or every recipe.